27cents

Monday, April 03, 2006

Impossible Uncertain Certainty

It takes negative capacity to live with a question.  Here’s what I mean by that:  it takes an amount of discomfort to process uncertainty.  “Discomfort”, here, being understated.  It’s more like “we hate it”.
 
In fact, I would suggest that our desire for an answer is sometimes so great that it can supercede the process of developing an honest answer.  Beyond even that, I would suggest that we sometimes crave certainty so much that we will let ourselves be convinced that we can have more of it than may be possible.
 
And now we come to the issue of certainty with Christ.  Perhaps, we have at times, projected a kind of candied, dressed up super-certainty that isn’t sustainable in the real world.  Who wouldn’t want an irrepressible, undefeatable, low-maintenance, complete certainty that requires no thought or care or attention? Who wouldn’t want to be blazingly certain for free?  It’s compelling.  And also, likely, dysfunctional.
 
We’ve trained entire batches of young people to believe that Christ was “simple” and “undeniable” and “proveable” and “obvious”; and then those young people went to University and found that Christ was anything but.  We trained them to live in the expectation of a certainty that was not sustainable in our half life of limited perspectives and fallen human nature.  Force to process this sudden conflict, many of them took it as evidence that they’d been scammed and left Christ for those in high school.  
 
Maybe we just should have told them that uncertainty is a part of life…  What about a faith that can survive the honest uncertainties of our limited perspectives?  Have we raised generations of certainty junkies?  What about teaching them about the pendulum-like movements of certainty swinging back and forth from clear to muddied and back again?  How true does a true thing need to seem?  What about increasing their negative capacity to live with their questions?  Maybe more of them could have carried their passion for Christ into University and beyond.  
 
Faith implies challenge when you read about it in scripture.  It implies stretching, it implies choice, it implies endeavor and development.  True, a time is coming when a conclusion about Christ cannot be avoided;  a time is coming when revelation will be complete and irresistible.  But by then, it will be too late to choose.  Christ will be face to face.  As for now, the choice is the point.  And we will never get to the place where we can be so certain we won’t need to get up tomorrow and CHOOSE to believe it all over, again.


5 Comments:

  • I would further suggest that high school students who take the "Christian-certainty" bait hook line and sinker is about the same percentage of high school students that graduate from their faith when they graduate from high school...

    It seems like a clear connection to me.

    By Blogger jeremy postal, at 9:13 PM  

  • Another area of great defeat to an authentic Christian faith that resonates from this idea of "Christian-certainty" is the one track Christian mind; that God is the only thing allowed to be important. Let me illustrate through Mark Noll (The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind)
    “I was brought up in a Christian environment where, because God had to be given pre-eminence, nothing else was allowed to be important. I have broken through to the position that because God exists, everything has significance”
    Christians were ambushed as soon as they stepped out of high school. What choice did Christian-certainty and Christian-orientation leave them..

    God forgive us what were we thinking...

    hugs and kisses,
    DSW

    By Blogger DSW, at 2:14 PM  

  • I couldn't agree more with what you write. This week we conclude a series "I Lve Jesus But Hate the Church: Living The Questions." I think the name for the new church is so appropriate in our time, The Thomas Question. People are looking for an authentic place to journey with others over life's questions. Peace be with you on the path...

    By Blogger Stew Carson, at 7:07 PM  

  • This echos a lot of my journey over the past couple years. Wrestling with not having certainty on said issue used to drive me crazy, and I'd fear being confronted on these issues of faith because I didn't have the black or white.

    The acknowledgment of the grey in life, and the realization that not having the answer was ok, was one of the most freeing experiences of my life.

    I guess that ties in with the "free-ing-ness" (that can't be a word...) that comes with challenging and reshaping and destroying of the pillers of personal theology, and the sacred cows that graze those theological plains.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:32 AM  

  • I'm all for not taking a conversaion with Christ for granted with lazy certainty and perhaps be guilty of maintaing what Bonoeffer called a cheap grace.
    On the other hand an uncertainty that pokes me to reevaluate the integrity and authenticity of my Christ conversation sounds healthy

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:41 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home